DISNEY
PRINCESSES
OR
DO I REALLY WANT MY DAUGHTER TO ASPIRE TO BE A
PRINCESS?
They look
picture perfect, hair done, beautiful dresses and perfect bodies and they always get their man. Of course through their movie there are tragic moments-
heartbreak, betrayal, and murder. I can't think of more than a handful of Disney movies where a movie doesn't have a parent die a violent death, and yet the
girls all come out roses and perfection on the other side. Their hair
might get messy and their dresses a little mussed on the way but none of them
ever seem to really have a hard time to get through or a real defining moment
where they are saving themselves rather than waiting for someone else to save
them- or they are willing to go to really long lengths to get to a man... Not
exactly a lesson I want MY daughters having ingrained into their
little psyches.
I mean
really if you look at it, the image really does say it all doesn't it? I want my
daughters to be strong, independent women and each of the princesses are
enslaved by the rules of a male-driven society and even their
"princes" are liars, weirdos (let's kiss the dead chick; let's lie
our ass off and hope she doesn't recognize me; let's hold her hostage until she
gives in to Stockholm Syndrome)
Also not
really teaching our son's too good of habits on how to treat our daughters
either, huh?
BUT, I am
not only looking at the cartoon princesses when I make my argument against
Disney's Princess Program. Just look at the child stars that have gone from
squeaky clean girls- ones you think are good role models for your girls to
watch- the 90's had Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera. All seemingly sweet
and innocent Mickey Mouse Club girls who grew up and into some really bad
messes.
We all
know that songs like "Slave 4 U" by Britney was
a blatant sex sells hit- she was dancing with a snake for heaven's
sake... But did you ever really listen to the lyrics of
the sugary sweet lyrics of "Genie in a Bottle"? or
another blatantly sexual "Dirrty" turned the nice girl next door role
models into sex objects- and our girls were still their devoted fans hanging on
every trend. Disney's little angels were running amok with our females
firmly in tow. Britney turned to drugs, drinking, was in and out of facilities
due to mental health issues and hard partying and Christina's life wasn't any
more innocent.
Today's
generation is even worse- there are so many names out there- so many actresses
that go from wonderful pretty girls on the Disney shows and movies we think are
safe for our girls to be fans of- think Hannah Montana, Wizards of Waverly
Place, High School Musical, and Parent Trap to name a few. Child stars like
Selena Gomez, Lindsay Lohan, Vanessa Hudgens, and of course Miley Cyrus have gone
from good girls with cute spunky personalities and are well covered
clothing-wise. Yet, as they get older we have skimpier outfits, more partying,
drugs, DUIs and worse- and again these are the young women that our daughters
emulate- the real life Disney Princesses.
I'm sorry but I really
don't want my daughters thinking-read worshiping- (and lets face it
pop media boarders on worship these days) - or that
partying, drinking drugs and multiple police encounters is
acceptable or even normal behavior. Look at the spectacle that
Lindsay Lohan has been making of herself for years now and yet we still watch
her like a hawk, love everything she does and she JUST went on Oprah after a
6th stay in rehabilitation.
Then there is good ol'
Miley. At 15, Miley was dating 20 year old male model, Justin Gaston and of
course in the same year was the notorious Vanity Fair shoot. Again Disney
Princess gone bad...not something I want my daughter watching, singing,
wearing, wanting to be like in any way shape or form.
So I look
at the movie shelves in my house- I see Cinderella, Snow White and all the
others and I question why I have all of them here. I don't have any of the new
movies- not the live action ones- my youngest loved Brave and The Princess and
the Frog, but I REFUSE to allow my kids to watch shows like Hannah Montana and
they have never seen High School Musical (my girls are 10 and 5). They look
blankly at you if you ask them who Lindsay Lohan or Miley Cyrus is and Wizards
of Waverly Place was allowed until Selena started going south as well.
Strangely enough, my daughters question the motives and actions of the
princesses as well, anyway. My oldest was watching Beauty and the Beast with me
and when the Beast lets Belle go and does his insanity imitation, she looked at
me and asked very seriously why he was throwing a temper tantrum. With Snow
White, she questions the weirdness of kissing a dead chick (her words)-
needless to say she isn't much of a princess fan anyway.
In my
opinion, whether it is the pressure of the environment more-so on the young
women than the young men of the Disney world- and Hollywood in general- there
is much more of a push to leave the "child princess" image behind and
Disney turns a blind eye to it or perhaps endorses it- at some point when
pretty much every female actress goes from good girl Disney princess starlet to
young woman boarder line or worse let's say party girl...
No, I think we will read Harry
Potter or the Monster High series instead and watch cartoons from the 1980's
and 1990's- when there were morals to the shows and the characters were fully
dressed.
I do have a problem with the Disney princes movies because it can teach girls that you can tame your abuser if you stay with them (Beauty and the Beast), you should change to get your man (The Little Mermaid and possible Cinderella), etc. I also agree that Christina Aguilera and Brittney Spear's songs were a LOT dirtier than I realized at the young age of 6. But, why should they stay the little girls that they once were? Why does Selena Gomez have to be the same innocent little girl that she was at 16 when she's 20 years old? Isn't that a little gross? I'd much rather see her move on from Disney and go do other movies as an adult. She is her own person. Miley Cyrus was dating a 20 year old at 15, yes, and that is a little weird, but why blame her? She's the minor and he is the adult. Of course there are other factors there (he was a close family friend and her parents had known him for a long time) but she should not be called a wrong for that. Same with the picture: that was inappropriate for the photographer to take. I agree that I'd rather have my children watch or read Harry Potter because Hermione Granger is a much more independent character than most of the Disney Princesses. And I honestly do get the point of wanting our son's and daughter's to have good roll models and I wouldn't want my future 6 year old to be acting the same way Miley Cyrus is acting now. But they are still adults and they are probably done with the whole Disney thing now anyway.
ReplyDeleteSo with this I agree, and disagree. I agree with the fact that they are being sexualized, and taking things maybe a bit further than needed. There are few stars that have come a long way from being affiliated with disney, but for some reason the only ones I can think of are men. It seems as if Justin Timberlake and Ryan Gosling are the only ones who were able to get away from the disney image in a positive way. But is that because they are men? I think that has a lot to do with it. They aren't held to the same pressures as women. Women have to be sexy in order to be "liked". It's been that way as long as I can remember. Brittney was 16 when 'One More Time' came out. And I remember watching the video with my mom thinking I wanted to be her because she was so pretty. I didn't realize that she was being sexual because I didn't know what anything meant. I think that with today's society, and the upcoming generation, it's good to not let them act the way that these celebrities are acting, but at the same time, its better for them to know what's going on and know not to aspire to be that because they are better than that and have more to offer than sex or acting sexual to get what they want/ people to like them.
ReplyDelete