Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Illness as an Asset not a Disease



ILLNESS AS AN ASSET
NOT A DISEASE

In the media today if a male character has some sort of mental illness it is usually used as a sort of asset rather than the true life debilitating disease that these illnesses are- causing more misconceptions and stigmas than ever in real life. 


Men with mental illnesses have been lacking in the media unless their mental illness gives them some sort of an advantage. In dramatic shows like Perception or Dexter or Monk the main character- a man- has some mental illness but it is used as a character asset rather than a flaw. 

In Monk, his OCD- a debilitating disease ruining the lives of millions of people makes him a rather "super detective" because he notices every little detail- I am not saying that this can't be the case but the show takes a serious mental illness and places it in a tidy little box of look how amazing and it is -he is a wonder.The fact that the character has this disease is touched on and the main source of conflict but it isn't treated or managed and there isn't any sort of stigma removal to be found. 



In Perception, another television drama, the main character, Danial is a professor who also has Schizophrenia- in this drama his hallucinations  he refuses to take medications or treatments- often assist his possessing of the crime scenes he works with the FBI. Again, this media image gives a terrible view of a mental illness- while truthfully I love the show and am an avid watcher myself, I find that looking at in context his disease is being used again as a sort of "added power" and not as a debilitating illness at all- though I will give there are some episodes that touch on his inward struggle with his decision to not medicate and a large part of the show's dynamic comes from his lack of social skill-set and mental illness it is still a very flawed and rosy view of a dark and ugly disease.



In Dexter, the main character is a sociopath who kills on a moral code. He has a terrible tragic history leaving him mentally ill and instead of his father getting him counseling  hello??? the man teaches him how to be the perfect killer instead. OKKKKKK...
Now, I love Dexter- it is rife with twists and turns and draws you in and his character development is amazing- BUT he is still an anti-hero with a disease that is used as a prop for a story line.



Some other shows where the main male character has a mental illness are shows like Prison Break where the Micheal plans several elaborate plots and uncovers schemes left and right due to a condition called Low Latent Inhibition- a condition where he processes every aspect of everything he sees- literally breaking apart in his mind everything he sees daily. He then transposed his plan into an amazing work of tattoo art and gets it placed on his body.


What you don't see in the media are the every day men who fight a battle just to get out of bed- who battle OCD and PTSD and a number of other mental illnesses and are the true heroes these men don't fit into tidy character boxes. We are shown characters with one illness that they seem to magically overcome or use to their advantage- and don't get me wrong- many men (and women-myself included) live very full lives with multiple mental illnesses; but they are not the stuff of movie magic they are made out to be in the pictures. 

We are being spoon fed ideas about mental health and the overlying idea it seems is that a man should be able to use it to his advantage or at least get over it. 




2 comments:

  1. I have to agree with you on how television represents mental illnesses as a benefactor primarily torwards men. It's odd that its portrayed that way, but it makes me wonder that maybe its not such a bad thing? People with mental illnesses are often negatively discriminated but maybe shows like Monk and Perception help by showing people suffering in a positive light. Dexter, however isn't someone we should look up to.
    When it comes to film I think that mental illnesses are more accurately represented. Films such as A Beautiful Mind, Shutter Island, Black Swan, and even Fight Club depict schizophrenia in a way that debilitates the characters lives albeit a bit unrealistically. Which actually makes me question why films tend to take the negative route while tv makes it a positive thing. Maybe those primetime media moguls find it too risky to depict mental illnesses realistically.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Being on both sides of this coin- both knowing those with illnesses and being a person with them myself I see both sides of the coin here. there are some definite highs from the illnesses that can be obtained- some geniuses are reputed to have had mental illnesses and suffered throughout their lives- as well as the downfall of such illnesses.

    People like Our media friend Dexter and sociopaths in real life. It is a touchy subject but ultimately I think it puts an unhealthy burden on men who DO suffer these illnesses to "MAN UP" or "GET OVER IT".

    ReplyDelete